NewThe guide: 11 paywall examples

9 minutes

7 numbers to look at before saying your paywall converts well

Your paywall converts at 12%. Good news? Not necessarily. If your subscribers cancel quickly or systematically choose the cheapest offer, you may be leaving important revenue on the table.

Clément Parot

7 numbers to look at before saying your paywall converts well

Article summary

  • A paywall that converts better is not necessarily a paywall that brings in more.
  • An excellent paywall does not help much if the majority of your users never see it.
  • The number of free trials is an intermediate indicator, not a final economic goal.
  • If you look only at conversion, you risk choosing the wrong variant.
  • The goal is not to get the largest possible number of subscribers. It is to generate more revenue per user, durably.

Summarize this article with

You have just launched a new paywall.

Your conversion rate goes from 8% to 12%.

+50% conversion.

You are happy. And that is normal.

But one question remains unanswered: is your application actually making more money?

Because a paywall that converts better is not necessarily a paywall that brings in more.

It can attract users who cancel quickly, favor the cheapest subscriptions, or generate lots of free trials that never become paid.

At firstapp, we support B2C mobile applications in optimizing their monetization.

And to make the right decisions, we never look at the conversion rate alone.

Here are the 7 indicators to understand if your application is actually monetizing its users well.

1. Download-to-Paid: how many downloads become subscribers?

Download-to-Paid measures the share of users who download your application and become paying subscribers.

Formula:

Download-to-Paid = (new paying users / downloads) × 100

For a rigorous measurement, users must belong to the same cohort and have an identical conversion window.

Imagine an application with:

  • 10,000 downloads.
  • 300 new paying subscribers.

Its Download-to-Paid conversion rate is 3%.

It is an important indicator, because it lets you measure your application's overall ability to turn its downloads into revenue.

But it does not let you understand where users drop off.

For that, you have to analyze the funnel.

Newsletter

Once a week.

Last issue

We opened 10 apps to see how they sell a subscription.

+534 people read us each week

2. Paywall-to-Paid: does your paywall actually convert?

Paywall-to-Paid measures the share of users exposed to the paywall who become paying subscribers.

Take two applications with 10,000 downloads each.

IndicatorApplication AApplication B
Downloads10,00010,000
Users exposed to the paywall3,0007,000
Paywall-to-Paid15%8%
New paying subscribers450560

Application A has a better conversion rate on its paywall.

Yet application B generates more subscribers.

Why?

Because it exposes many more users to its offer.

An excellent paywall does not help much if the majority of your users never see it.

That is why we always analyze the paywall exposure rate alongside its conversion.

3. Trial-to-Paid: how many free trials actually become paid?

Many applications try to maximize the number of free trials.

But starting a trial does not mean becoming a paying subscriber.

Imagine two paywalls:

IndicatorPaywall APaywall B
Free trials started500350
Trial-to-Paid conversion30%60%
New paying subscribers150210

Paywall A generates more trials.

But paywall B generates more paying subscribers.

That can be explained in particular by differences in how the offer is presented, the trial length, or user intent.

The number of free trials is an intermediate indicator, not a final economic goal.

You also have to measure cancellations, refunds, and the revenue generated after the trial.

4. ARPU: how much does a user actually bring in?

ARPU (Average Revenue Per User) is the average revenue generated per user over a defined period.

Formula:

ARPU = revenue over the period / number of users in the population studied

The exact definition of the population is essential: active users, installs, or registered users do not give the same result.

Take an application that generates €10,000 in monthly revenue with 5,000 active users over the month.

Its monthly ARPU is €2 per active user.

This indicator lets you understand the monetization of your audience as a whole.

But be careful: do not confuse it with ARPPU (Average Revenue Per Paying User), which measures the average revenue of paying users.

ARPU vs ARPPU: what is the difference?

Imagine an application with:

  • 10,000 active users.
  • 500 paying users.
  • €5,000 in revenue over the month.

Its monthly ARPU is €0.50.

Its monthly ARPPU is €10.

The two indicators answer different questions.

ARPU lets you evaluate the overall monetization of the audience.

ARPPU lets you understand how much the users who pay bring in.

5. Revenue Per Install: how much does each download bring in?

Revenue Per Install (RPI) measures the average revenue generated per install over a given horizon.

Formula:

RPI = revenue attributed to an install cohort / number of installs in that cohort

It is a particularly useful indicator for comparing monetization experiments.

Imagine two paywall variants exposed to cohorts of 1,000 new installs each.

IndicatorVariant AVariant B
Installs1,0001,000
Paid conversion10%8%
New subscribers10080
Revenue at D30€600€800
RPI at D30€0.60€0.80

Variant A converts more users.

But variant B generates 33% more revenue per install over the first 30 days.

If you look only at conversion, you risk choosing the wrong variant.

RPI lets you bring monetization performance closer to acquisition volume.

It is particularly interesting when you are trying to determine whether an application can invest more in paid acquisition.

6. LTV: how much is a user worth over time?

LTV (Lifetime Value) is the economic value generated by a user over their relationship with your application.

Depending on the tools and methods, it can correspond to an observed value or to an estimate of future revenue.

You therefore always have to specify the definition used.

Why LTV is essential

Imagine two applications.

The first generates lots of monthly subscriptions, but its users cancel quickly.

The second converts less, but keeps its subscribers longer.

The second can generate more revenue per user over time.

That is why we recommend tracking LTV at several horizons, for example at 30, 90, or 180 days, depending on cohort maturity.

Watch out for misleading comparisons

A 30-day LTV should not be compared directly with a 12-month LTV.

Likewise, a predictive LTV is not equivalent to an LTV actually observed.

To compare two variants, use an identical calculation method and horizon.

LTV lets you look beyond the first payment and evaluate the value created over time.

7. Retention: how long do your subscribers stay?

Retention measures your application's ability to keep its users or its subscribers over time.

You have to distinguish two notions.

Product retention: do users keep using the application?

Subscription retention: do users keep paying?

These two indicators can move differently.

A user can keep their subscription without opening the application regularly.

Conversely, a user can stay active on a free offer without generating revenue.

Why retention changes everything

Imagine two applications that offer a subscription at €10 per month.

The first keeps its subscribers for two months on average.

The second keeps them for six months.

In this simplified example, with no discount, refund, or fees, a subscriber generates €20 and €60 of revenue respectively.

The difference is considerable.

An improvement in retention can have as much economic impact as an improvement in initial conversion, and sometimes more.

8. How do you use these 7 indicators to make better decisions?

These metrics should not be analyzed independently.

They let you understand different stages of monetization.

IndicatorMain question
Download-to-PaidAre we turning enough downloads into subscribers?
Paywall-to-PaidDoes our offer convince the users who see it?
Trial-to-PaidDo our free trials become paid?
ARPUHow much does our audience bring in?
Revenue Per InstallHow much does each install generate?
LTVWhat value does a user produce over time?
RetentionHow long do we keep our users and subscribers?

Example: an A/B test that increases conversion, but not revenue

Imagine you test a new presentation of your paywall.

Variant B improves conversion by 20%.

But it sharply increases the share of the cheapest monthly subscriptions.

At D30, revenue per install stays identical.

At D90, it is lower than variant A's.

In that case, declaring variant B the winner solely because of its conversion rate would be a mistake.

You have to define a primary metric before launching the test and wait until the cohorts are mature enough.

At firstapp, our approach is to analyze the revenue generated by users, not only their behavior on a screen.

Conclusion: a good paywall is not summed up by its conversion rate

A paywall can convert at 15% and generate less revenue than a paywall that converts at 10%.

It all depends on prices, free trials, the subscriptions chosen, and how long users stay paying.

That is why optimizing conversion alone can lead to bad decisions.

The goal is not to get the largest possible number of subscribers. It is to generate more revenue per user, durably.

At firstapp, we help subscription mobile applications improve their monetization through experimentation on paywalls, onboarding, pricing, and retention.

Want to understand where your application is losing revenue?

Discover firstapp

FAQ: a mobile application's monetization indicators

What is the difference between ARPU and LTV?

ARPU measures the average revenue generated per user over a defined period. LTV measures the value generated or estimated over a user's lifetime, or over a specified cohort horizon.

What is the difference between ARPU and ARPPU?

ARPU takes into account every user in the population studied, while ARPPU takes into account only paying users.

What is a good conversion rate for a mobile application?

It depends on the monetization model, the category, the market, and the measurement window. Freemium applications and applications with a hard paywall, in particular, show different performance.

Why does my paywall convert well, but my revenue stagnates?

Several factors can explain it: low paywall exposure, free trials that do not become paid, prices that are too low, weak retention, or changes in the subscription mix.

Which KPI should you prioritize to optimize a paywall?

Revenue per install over a defined horizon is often a relevant metric, because it takes conversion and revenue into account. It should be completed by retention, LTV, and the metrics specific to the test.

Newsletter

Once a week.

Last issue

We opened 10 apps to see how they sell a subscription.

+534 people read us each week