NewThe guide: 11 paywall examples

12 minutes

Hard paywall vs soft paywall: how to choose

According to RevenueCat, a hard paywall converts at about 10.7% from install, versus 2.1% for freemium. Adapty, which measures the paywall view, gives the advantage to the soft paywall.

Clément Parot

Hard paywall vs soft paywall: how to choose

Article summary

  • According to RevenueCat, hard paywalls convert at about 10.7%, versus 2.1% for freemium.
  • Airbridge reports 12.1% conversion at 35 days for hard paywalls, versus 2.2% for freemium.
  • At the moment the paywall is shown, Adapty measures 4.85% for the soft paywall and 3.34% for the hard paywall.
  • Fitness apps have the highest trial-to-paid rate of any category, at 35%, according to RevenueCat.
  • A case documented by RevenueCat describes an app whose revenue was multiplied by 5 with a dismissible paywall at the start of onboarding.

Summarize this article with

Hard paywall or soft paywall: it is one of the first structural decisions for a subscription mobile app. And it is also one of the most debated in the industry, because the data does not give a simple answer.

firstapp works with founders on monetizing their apps from launch. What we see: both models work. In different contexts, with different user profiles, at different stages.

This article will not decide for you. It will give you the data so you can.

Hard paywall and soft paywall: clear definitions

Before comparing, let's set the basics.

A hard paywall blocks access to the app from the start. The user cannot use the features without subscribing or starting a trial. They can sometimes browse a limited "preview" version, but the product's real value stays inaccessible until payment. This is the model of FitnessAI, Noom, or most premium health and productivity apps.

A soft paywall lets the user access part of the product for free, with no time limit. Access to certain features or a certain volume of use is then tied to a subscription. This is the freemium model: Spotify, Duolingo, MyFitnessPal. The user builds a habit before paying. Notion, on a soft paywall, shows the price when you hit a limit.

The fundamental difference: with a hard paywall, the user pays before experiencing the full value. With a soft paywall, they experience part of it before deciding.

Newsletter

Once a week.

Last issue

We opened 10 apps to see how they sell a subscription.

+534 people read us each week

Hard paywall: what the data says

The conversion numbers

This is the hard paywall's strong point. The data is clear on this.

According to RevenueCat (State of Subscription Apps 2025 and 2026), hard paywalls convert at about 10.7% versus 2.1% for freemium. That is 5 times better. On the D35 metric (conversion 35 days after install), Airbridge reports 12.1% for hard paywalls versus 2.2% for freemium, or 5.5 times better.

The logic behind these numbers is simple: the hard paywall filters. Users who pass an immediate paywall are the ones who already have a strong purchase intent. The conversion rate reflects that selection, not an intrinsic performance of the model.

LTV

A second documented advantage: long-term value per paying user.

According to the Adapty State of In-App Subscriptions 2026 report, apps with a hard paywall generate a 1-year LTV 21% higher than apps with a soft paywall. Adapty's data also shows that users who pass a hard paywall spend 20% to 33% more than the median.

The explanation: these are high-intent users who agreed to pay without having fully experienced the product. That profile is structurally more likely to renew.

Simplicity of development and measurement

A practical advantage often underestimated: a hard paywall is simpler to build and to optimize.

There is only one user journey. No managing a free experience in parallel with a premium experience. No decision about which features to gate and which to leave open. No risk that the free version is too generous and kills conversion. And the metrics are clear: paywall conversion, trial-to-paid, LTV.

The limits

The hard paywall carries real risks.

The main one: drop-off before the paywall even appears. Users who do not yet have a reason to pay, because they have not experienced the value, leave the app before seeing the payment screen. This is especially strong for apps whose value is hard to communicate in a few onboarding screens.

Second limit: volume. By letting fewer users into the funnel, you mechanically shrink the size of your base. For apps that depend on mass (social networks, content apps) or network effects, that is a structural brake.

Soft paywall: what the data says

Higher conversion at the paywall, according to some data

Here is a point of tension in the 2026 data.

The Adapty State of In-App Subscriptions 2026 report shows that soft paywalls convert better at the moment the paywall is shown: 4.85% versus 3.34% for hard paywalls, or about 50% more on this specific metric.

The nuance matters: this metric measures only users who see the paywall, not those who install the app. It does not contradict RevenueCat's numbers, which measure conversion from install. Both are true at the same time: the soft paywall brings more users to the payment screen, but the hard paywall starts with a high-intent user base from the outset.

Habit building

The soft paywall rests on a documented behavioral principle: the more a user builds a tool into their routine, the harder it is to give it up.

By leaving access to a functional free version, you let the user build a habit before you ask them to pay. When the paywall arrives (quota used up, a desired premium feature), the purchase decision is made in a context of value already experienced.

MyFitnessPal illustrates this model: 220 million registered users, 30 million monthly actives. The majority free, with a fraction that converts to premium. Volume offsets the lower per-user conversion rate.

Retention data

The soft paywall can generate better retention among users who convert, depending on the context. According to RevenueCat, how a subscriber was acquired is the variable that most influences their long-term retention. A user who had time to experience the value before paying is structurally different from a user who paid on faith.

That said, this finding is not universal. It depends heavily on the category.

The limits

The soft paywall has its own traps.

First risk: "free-riders", users who use the product for free indefinitely and never convert. If the free version is too generous, this segment can grow to the point of weighing on infrastructure costs without ever contributing revenue.

Second risk: development complexity. Maintaining two user journeys (free and premium) and deciding which features to gate is a delicate exercise. Too restrictive, and it looks like a hard paywall with extra steps. Not restrictive enough, and conversion does not exist.

Third risk: diluted metrics. With a soft paywall, it is harder to isolate what actually drives conversion, because users are at very different stages of their journey when they see the paywall.

The 2026 data paradox

There is a contradiction in the market data that it is honest to flag.

RevenueCat (115,000+ apps analyzed) and Adapty (16,000+ apps) publish numbers that seem to oppose each other on some points. RevenueCat shows a clear advantage for the hard paywall in conversion from install. Adapty shows an advantage for the soft paywall in conversion from the paywall view.

These two metrics measure different things. One measures the effectiveness of the full funnel (install to payment). The other measures the effectiveness of the payment screen alone (view to payment).

The difference in scope between the two reports (115k vs 16k apps) can also explain representation bias depending on the app categories that dominate each dataset.

What that means for you: both models have data that supports them. There is no universal answer in the aggregated numbers. Your app's context is decisive.

When to choose a hard or soft paywall

Neither wins systematically. What guides the choice is the nature of your app and your users.

The hard paywall makes sense when

Your app's value can be communicated effectively in a short onboarding. If a user can understand why your app is worth paying for in a few screens, a hard paywall is viable.

Arrival intent is strong. Productivity, health, fitness, or specific-niche apps attract users who know what they are looking for. RevenueCat's data confirms that fitness apps have the highest trial-to-paid rate of any category: 35%. A high-intent user profile can absorb a hard paywall without churn.

You are in the launch phase and you need revenue quickly. The hard paywall generates revenue earlier in the app's life cycle, with fewer users in the funnel.

The soft paywall makes sense when

Your app's value takes time to experience. If the user needs several sessions to understand why your app is useful, blocking them from the start produces churn before the paywall.

You want to maximize volume. For apps whose model depends on a mass of users (social networks, content apps, apps with network effects), the soft paywall is often the only viable model.

Your market is sensitive to perceived risk. In categories where the average user hesitates to pay without having tried (creative apps, generalist productivity tools), the soft paywall reduces entry friction.

What the category says

Fitness apps convert at 35% trial-to-paid: hard paywalls work particularly well there because the value is immediate and concrete (a workout, a nutrition plan).

Entertainment apps convert at 19.1% trial-to-paid: the value is more subjective, the habit takes longer to build, and the soft paywall is structurally a better fit.

The hybrid paywall

Mentioning the hybrid is not dodging the question. It is a documented reality.

Some apps place their paywall at the start of onboarding, but make it dismissible, meaning the user can skip it and access a limited version. This is neither a pure hard paywall nor a classic soft paywall. It is a compromise between filtering intent and reducing drop-off.

According to a case documented by RevenueCat, an app that moved its paywall to the start of onboarding and made it dismissible multiplied its revenue by 5. The key: the paywall is shown earlier (hard paywall vibe), but the absolute friction is removed (soft paywall safety net).

This approach has an analytical advantage: it lets you observe who chooses to skip and understand at what moment those users eventually convert (or do not). That is a valuable source of data for adjusting your strategy.

FAQ

What is the difference between a hard paywall and a soft paywall?

A hard paywall blocks full access to the app until payment or the start of a trial. A soft paywall lets the user access part of the product for free, with no time limit, and only blocks certain features or volumes of use. The main difference: with a hard paywall, the user commits before having fully experienced the value. With a soft paywall, they experience it before deciding.

Which paywall converts better?

The answer depends on what you measure. From install, hard paywalls convert about 5 times better than freemium according to RevenueCat (10.7% vs 2.1%). From the paywall view, Adapty shows that soft paywalls convert 50% better (4.85% vs 3.34%). These metrics do not measure the same thing. In 1-year LTV, hard paywalls generate 21% more revenue per paying user according to Adapty 2026. There is no universal answer: your app's context, your category, and your launch stage are decisive.

Does a soft paywall hurt monetization?

Not necessarily. A soft paywall can hurt monetization if the free version is too generous, if usage limits are poorly calibrated, or if the premium onboarding is not designed separately from the free onboarding. When it is well executed, though, it converts users who would never have passed a hard paywall, increasing total revenue volume even with a lower per-user conversion rate.

Can you change paywall model after launch?

Yes, and testing is even recommended. What the data suggests: do not lock onto a model without confronting it with the reality of your users. 82% of trials start on day 0 according to RevenueCat SOSA 2025, which means the decision to try or not is made in the first minutes. Moving from a soft to a hard paywall (or the reverse) is a strategic A/B test that can have a significant impact on LTV, and not only on the immediate conversion rate.

Is there a recommended model for apps in the launch phase?

The data points toward a hard paywall with a trial for the launch phase, mainly for two reasons: it generates revenue earlier, and it filters high-intent users from whom it is easier to build a product. That said, if your app needs time to demonstrate its value, a hard paywall that is too early can produce massive churn before the paywall even appears. The aha moment of your app has to come before the paywall, whichever model you choose.

Newsletter

Once a week.

Last issue

We opened 10 apps to see how they sell a subscription.

+534 people read us each week