Your annual subscription isn't selling? The problem may not be the price.
Your users almost all choose the monthly subscription, even though your annual plan lets them save 40%, 50%, sometimes more. Why?
Article summary
- A user does not only choose the cheapest offer. They choose the one that seems the most suitable, the most reassuring, and the most attractive at the moment they have to pay.
- The problem is therefore not necessarily that your annual subscription is too expensive. It may be that your user does not yet have a reason to commit for twelve months.
- The price has not changed. But in the second version, the user immediately understands the economic advantage of the annual subscription.
- The annual share is an intermediate indicator. It is not your final goal.
- The goal is not to sell more annual subscriptions. It is to generate more revenue per user.
Summarize this article with
You have a mobile application with two plans: €9.99 per month or €59.99 per year.
On paper, the annual is much more attractive.
Yet 70% of your new subscribers choose the monthly.
Your first reflex? Increase the annual discount.
But what if the problem was not the price?
A user does not only choose the cheapest offer. They choose the one that seems the most suitable, the most reassuring, and the most attractive at the moment they have to pay.
At firstapp, we support subscription mobile applications in optimizing their pricing, their paywalls, and their monetization.
Here is how to understand why your annual subscription sells poorly, and the experiments to consider to improve its performance.
1. Why do your users prefer the monthly subscription?
Imagine an application that offers two plans:
| Offer | Price | Cost over 12 months |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly | €9.99/month | €119.88 |
| Annual | €59.99/year | €59.99 |
The annual subscription saves almost 50% over a full year.
It therefore seems logical to think that the majority of users should choose it.
Yet several factors can favor the monthly.
The commitment seems smaller
A user discovering your application does not necessarily know whether they will still be using it in six months.
Paying €59.99 immediately can feel riskier than paying €9.99 today.
Even if the annual is economically more attractive over the long term.
The product's value is not demonstrated yet
If your user has not understood why they would need your application for several months, why would they take an annual subscription?
This is particularly important for applications that answer a one-off need.
An exam-prep application, for example, can struggle to sell an annual plan to someone whose exam is in three weeks.
The monthly seems more flexible
The monthly subscription gives the user more freedom.
They can try the application, evaluate its usefulness, and decide later whether they want to continue.
The problem is therefore not necessarily that your annual subscription is too expensive. It may be that your user does not yet have a reason to commit for twelve months.
Newsletter
Once a week.
Last issue
We opened 10 apps to see how they sell a subscription.
+534 people read us each week
2. Your paywall directly influences the subscription choice
Two applications can offer exactly the same prices and get very different monthly/annual splits.
Why?
Because the way the offers are presented influences the decision.
Take an example.
Version A: neutral presentation
- Monthly: €9.99/month.
- Annual: €59.99/year.
Version B: presentation oriented toward the annual
- Annual: €4.99/month, billed €59.99 per year.
- Monthly: €9.99/month.
- Mention: "Save 50% with the annual".
The price has not changed.
But in the second version, the user immediately understands the economic advantage of the annual subscription.
Be careful, though: the monthly equivalent must not hide the amount actually billed.
The total annual price and the billing frequency must stay clearly visible.
The order of the offers matters
If your monthly offer appears first, selected by default, and visually emphasized, you naturally steer attention toward it.
Conversely, putting the annual forward can change the purchase split.
It is not a performance guarantee.
It is a hypothesis worth testing.
3. Five experiments to sell more annual subscriptions
Experiment 1: select the annual by default
Hypothesis: a pre-selected annual offer can increase its share of new subscriptions.
Test two versions of your paywall:
- Variant A: monthly subscription selected by default.
- Variant B: annual subscription selected by default.
Keep the other elements identical to better isolate the effect of this change.
Measure: annual share, overall conversion, and revenue per install.
Experiment 2: show the monthly equivalent of the annual
Hypothesis: presenting the annual subscription as a monthly equivalent makes the comparison easier.
Instead of showing only "€59.99/year", you can present:
€4.99/month, billed €59.99 per year.
The user more easily sees the gap with a monthly offer at €9.99.
The total amount billed must stay explicit.
Measure: annual choice, conversion, and revenue per install.
Experiment 3: test different price gaps
Hypothesis: your current annual discount may not be optimal.
A 20% discount may be too small to offset the perceived commitment.
But a 70% discount can degrade the economic value of each subscription.
You can test different price structures, for example:
- Monthly: €9.99 / Annual: €79.99.
- Monthly: €9.99 / Annual: €59.99.
The goal is not to find the biggest possible discount.
It is to find the structure that maximizes revenue over a comparable horizon.
Measure: conversion, subscription mix, and LTV.
Experiment 4: strengthen long-term value
Hypothesis: showing the benefits of regular use can make the annual subscription more relevant.
For a fitness application, the argument can be progress over several months.
For a learning application, it can be building skills over time.
For a wellness application, day-to-day support.
The user has to understand why they might need your product beyond the first weeks.
Test: a presentation centered on immediate benefits versus a presentation that includes long-term benefits.
Measure: subscription mix, conversion, and revenue per install.
Experiment 5: test an annual paywall after a first experience
Hypothesis: users who have already discovered the product's value may be more willing to choose the annual.
Rather than presenting the same offer to everyone, you can compare different moments of exposure.
For example:
- Paywall immediately after onboarding.
- Paywall after a first significant experience.
The goal is to determine whether a better understanding of the product favors long-term commitment.
Measure: paywall exposure, annual share, Download-to-Paid, and revenue per install.
4. Careful: selling more annuals does not necessarily mean making more
This is probably the most important point in this article.
Imagine two versions of a paywall, each exposed to 1,000 users.
| Indicator | Variant A | Variant B |
|---|---|---|
| Paid conversion | 12% | 9% |
| New subscribers | 120 | 90 |
| Share of annual subscriptions | 30% | 60% |
| Annual subscriptions | 36 | 54 |
| Monthly subscriptions | 84 | 36 |
Variant B looks better for selling the annual.
Its share goes from 30% to 60%.
But let's look at the initial revenue with a monthly at €9.99 and an annual at €59.99.
Variant A
36 × €59.99 + 84 × €9.99 = €2,998.80.
Variant B
54 × €59.99 + 36 × €9.99 = €3,599.10.
In this example, variant B generates about 20% more initial gross cash collected, despite a lower overall conversion.
That does not mean it will necessarily be better over twelve months.
Variant A has more monthly subscribers, who can generate several renewals.
To make a good decision, you have to compare revenue over a coherent window and include renewals, refunds, and other economic factors.
The annual share is an intermediate indicator. It is not your final goal.
5. What if the real problem came from your onboarding?
You can offer a very attractive annual discount.
If your user does not understand why your application deserves to be used for several months, they may still choose the monthly.
That is why the annual strategy sometimes starts before the paywall.
Show the future value of the product
An onboarding that only presents features can be insufficient.
It can be more relevant to help the user project themselves into the results they could get with regular use.
Personalize the promise
If the user stated their goal during onboarding, you can use that information to make the value proposition more concrete.
A nutrition application can, for example, present support adapted to the stated goal.
Reduce uncertainty
The user has to understand what they get, how the subscription works, and what the renewal conditions are.
Trust plays an important role when it comes to paying a year in advance.
6. The indicators to track to optimize your monthly/annual mix
At firstapp, we recommend not running an annual strategy only with the percentage of new annual subscriptions.
Here are the indicators to analyze together.
| Indicator | Why track it? |
|---|---|
| Share of new annual subscriptions | Understand the offer split |
| Download-to-Paid | Measure overall conversion |
| Paywall-to-Paid | Measure offer performance |
| Revenue per install | Compare the revenue generated at equivalent acquisition |
| LTV at 30, 90, or 365 days | Compare economic value over a defined horizon |
| Retention and renewals | Evaluate how durable the revenue is |
| Refunds | Identify possible satisfaction or comprehension problems |
It is also important to distinguish new subscriptions from renewals.
A rise in the annual share among new purchases does not necessarily mean that the annual share of all active subscriptions increases immediately.
Conclusion: your annual subscription may not be missing a discount
If your users massively favor the monthly, lowering the annual price is not necessarily the right solution.
The problem can come from how the offer is presented, from the perceived commitment, or from the product's value.
Before changing your prices, analyze your subscription mix and test different ways of presenting the annual.
And above all, do not settle for measuring the proportion of users who choose this plan.
The goal is not to sell more annual subscriptions. It is to generate more revenue per user.
At firstapp, we support subscription mobile applications in optimizing their pricing, their paywalls, and their monetization journey.
Discover how firstapp can improve your application's monetization
FAQ: annual or monthly subscription for a mobile application
Why do users prefer monthly to annual?
Monthly can seem less committing and more flexible, even when the annual is economically more advantageous. The perceived value of the product, the initial price, and the expected length of use influence the choice.
What discount should you offer on an annual subscription?
There is no universal discount. The right gap depends on the monthly price, willingness to pay, retention, and the application's economic goals. Several price structures can be tested.
Should you select the annual by default on a paywall?
It can increase the visibility of the annual offer, but its effect on revenue has to be measured. The user must be able to clearly identify the selected offer, the amount billed, and the renewal frequency.
How do you increase the share of annual subscriptions?
You can test the hierarchy of the offers, the monthly equivalent, how the savings are presented, the long-term value arguments, and the moment the paywall is shown.
Is the annual subscription always more profitable?
No. It can improve initial cash collected, but its profitability depends on the price, the retention of monthly subscriptions, annual renewals, and the economic value generated over time.